The geometries of these studies are different: these experiments use a circular porous plug burner, Shtilman and Sivashinsky (1990) considered a square geometry with a large number of cells, Bayliss and Matkowsky (1992) considered a circular line propagating radially inward, and Nicolenko (1993) considered a square geometry with small number of cells. Each of these predicted disordered states is qualitatively similar to the experimental results shown in Figure lb.
The numerical simulations of Sivashinsky (1983) using the thermodiffusive model and of Michelson and Sivashinsky (1977, 1982) using the hydrodyanmical model both found a state in which the cells continually and chaotically recombine. It is not clear from the visual appearance of these states whether these numerical results correspond to a disordered state or to an intermittently ordered state.